Why “Canceling Christmas” was the Best Decision We Have Ever Made!

I’m afraid by putting my feelings into words somehow it will minimize the feeling we experienced this past Christmas morning. There was a magical and almost sacred feeling in our home and I hope that I can somehow convey that feeling to you reading this.

When we first started this journey (and before it became to the media…whatever it became to the media) it was just a hope. A hope that we could give our kids something more important this year, something they could keep forever. That we could help shape the way they were seeing the world and make them better men for it. I had faith that in future years they would be able to look back on this year with fondness and it would be remembered as being special. I also knew that it would most likely take a few years and some maturity before they could fully understand and appreciate why we did what we did this year. Thanks to a very special 5 year, that wasn’t the case.

It started about a week ago when our youngest son, Beckham, started wrapping things up and putting them under the tree. First it was pictures he had drawn, then small toys, and pretty soon he had gone through a whole roll of wrapping paper. His older brothers saw this and suddenly they wanted in. Every box in our house that was empty would disappear within minutes, be filled, wrapped, and placed under the tree. Every time I walked into my room the wrapping stuff had been pulled out and was all over the floor. I wasn’t involved at all with what was being wrapped and sat back and just watched as this happened.


Christmas Eve came and the boys were so excited! More excited than usual. They set out cookies for Santa without waiting for us and were so anxious to place the carrot and rosemary wreath outside for the reindeer. I was getting worried thinking that somehow they hadn’t really understood that Santa wasn’t coming. We do a slumber party every Christmas Eve in our room. When they had all settled down I told them that I was going to be placing an ornament in their stocking (like we do each year) and reminded them that was all there would be. Santa wasn’t going to be coming to our house to leave toys, just to get a snack for him and the reindeer. They said they understood and it was okay.

In the morning they were so happy to find the cookies and wreath had been eaten and Santa had actually left them a piece of See’s candy, a sucker, and a special letter to each of them. We ate our traditional breakfast and the boys were giddy to pass all the presents out. There were 8 or 9 presents for each of them, all from each other. And that’s when the magic happened. They had not wrapped up small meaningless toys, they had given each other the best of what they all individually had. They gave the things that mattered most to them. You could see they were filled with joy and delight on the looks of their brother’s faces when they saw what they had received. I know they also felt loved when they saw they had been given something that meant so much to the brother it was from.

Don’t get me wrong, there were still some silly things inside. Beckham is our little pack rat and thinks throwing anything away is a crime. We always find “trash stashes” of things he has confiscated from the trash. It wasn’t surprising to see that one of the presents Caleb opened was a lightbulb that we had thrown away a few days before. Caleb’s reaction was priceless! He held it above his head and said, “Look Beckham gave me a prop because I always have so many good ideas!” It was so funny and so amazing that something meaningless to most kids was something he actually appreciated and took the time to care about. We tried to tell him it was okay to throw away later and he said, “I want to keep it because Beckham really wanted me to have it.” He only relented to sneaking it into the trash when we told it was for safety because of the glass.


We sought out this month to teach our kids a lesson about giving and kindness, and in the end it was them who taught us. They faced what so many kids would have seen as the worst Christmas ever and turned it into the best Christmas for themselves and certainly for us as their parents. It is no wonder that the Savior wanted us to be like little children.

Matthew 18: 2-4
 2 And Jesus called a little child unto him, and set him in the midst of them,
 3 And said, Verily I say unto you, Except ye be converted, and become as little children, ye shall not enter into the kingdom of heaven.
 4 Whosoever therefore shall humble himself as this little child, the same is greatest in the kingdom of heaven.

There is more I want to write about the logistics of how we deliberately created giving opportunities for them throughout the whole month. I do not think you would get the same results if done in anger, and if you did not take the time to still make Christmas magical. But when done in a positive and loving way I think “Canceling Christmas” can be a wonderful, life changing experience.

Most of all I am very grateful for my boys. They got a bad reputation that they did not deserve at all. They truly are amazing! I am also grateful for a better appreciation of the power of love and sacrifice. I felt the true message of Christ’s birth and life permeate my heart in a new and powerful way.

I hope you all had a Merry Christmas and that this new year you find joy and happiness!



Previous author of Over the Big Moon. I shared my passion for home and family life! I love graphic design, DIY projects, cooking, and working in my garden! My favorite role is taking care of my husband and our 3 amazing and busy boys!

Comments (11)

  • Hello Lisa,
    My first time hearing about your blog, and it was from a Catholic radio when they aired your story. I can relate to you as I have 3 boys as well. I’m simply in awe of how you come about of canceling Christmas and how well your sons come to accept that it was all about Christ and giving. You are amazing is all I can say.

  • I may be coming in a bit late here Lisa but I wanted to let you know that I think you did a wonderful thing that they will remember forever. I Love that your boys made and gave gifts on their own. You rock! I am a Kindergarten teacher and every year I have my children exchange names and make a gift for their friend. It’s one of the highlights of the year for me to watch them give the gift and to watch them graciously receive the gifts. Keep up the good fight mama! I have 3 boys of my own and I LOVE it! Blessings to you

  • Mallory @ Classy Clutter

    Proud of you and your sweet family Lisa! What a wonderful Christmas they will always remember! xoxo

  • As Psychology professional, the initial story about you “Canceling Christmas” was disturbing. In some respects every parent deals with childhood selfishness in a different way. The initial articles made it sound like you were simply taking Christmas away from your children. While I still do not belive we can throw a band aid on years of parenting, I can appreciate the lessons you taught your children during their “giving month”. As our children have grown up we have had them involved with verious service projects and the soup kitchen, we served along side of our kids showing them the way. It’s not always easy, uphill battle we have as parents is never-ending. Hopefully this experience will carry all of you in to positive habits for the coming year. God bless.

    • Please take the time to read my original posts. The news was very shady in its coverage of what I actually wrote. I was very clear in my original posts about how we were still celebrating all aspects of Christmas besides getting presents from Santa and Mom and Dad. I believe we celebrated what Christmas is really suppose to mean and took away the commercialized version we have all be fed to believe Christmas really is. Happy New Year!

  • This is the first time I’ve heard or read about this. This literally put me to tears. Sounds like you and your husband achieved success; it also sounds like you have some VERY wonderful boys. Merry Christmas (Belated). Glad your’s was as wonderful as ever.

  • Heidi Schilling Fowler

    Congrats, Lisa. I’m so glad it was all you hoped and more! It sounds like you fostered the perfect atmosphere to help the kids create their own REAL Christmas.

  • I am so glad you followed up with this! Such a beautiful life event <3 Merry Christmas and may y'all have the most peace-filled new year yet.

Comments are closed.

Exploring all phases of life. 

© Over The Big Moon - All Rights Reserved

The images, tutorials and content on overthebigmoon.com are protected by copyright laws. DO NOT distribute or copy the content or share multiple images (including collage images) without written permission. DO NOT edit, crop, or remove watermarks from any image. For questions contact us at pam@overthebigmoon.com. This site contains affiliate links, which means that I may get a small commission if you decide to purchase anything from suggested companies. I recommend products that I use and love myself or that I think would be a helpful resource. Using these affiliate links to make your purchase helps support Over the Big Moon and allows me to continue to provide you with quality posts. You will not be paying anymore if items are purchased through affiliate links.